Get HCM digital magazine and ezines FREE
Sign up here ▸
Jobs   News   Features   Products   Magazine      Advertise  
NEWS
Scottish FA labels PFA 'misleading' over pitch survey
POSTED 15 Feb 2016 . BY Matthew Campelli
Hamilton Academical is one of the Scottish league teams with an artificial pitch
The Scottish Football Association (SFA) has queried the timing of survey results published by the Professional Footballers’ Association (PFA) in relation to artificial pitches, and labelled statements made by the body “misleading”.

Last week, the PFA published the results which revealed 73 per cent of the 705 professional players questioned would rather play on deteriorating grass than a 3G pitch, while 72 per cent believed that synthetic pitches were more likely to cause injuries.

However, the SFA said that it was “surprised” by the timing of publication, as the results formed part of a joint survey between the SFA and PFA – the Professional Player & Artificial Turf survey – conducted in 2013.

The governing body also said comments made by PFA chief executive Fraser Wishart about the variance in pitch quality and the risks they pose to players were “misleading”.

“While most players, given the choice, said they would prefer to play on natural grass, it is inaccurate and misleading to say ‘the vast majority of players wanted to avoid astroturf’. In actual fact, 42.5 per cent of respondents supported the use of synthetic surfaces in competitive matches,” said the SFA via a statement.

The SFA added that all 3G pitches used in league competition in Scotland are “required to be annually certified” to FIFA standards to satisfy Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL) rules.

“The SPFL has also implemented an innovative ‘spot-testing’ protocol to ensure these standards are maintained throughout the season – the only league in the world to do so,” the statement continued.

A piece of British Medical Journal research – titled Risk of Injury on 3G Artificial Turf in Norwegian Professional Football – was put forward by the SFA. It showed that 17.1 injuries were incurred per 1,000 matches on natural grass compared with 17.6 injuries on artificial turf.

The SFA concluded: “Finally we welcome Fraser’s request to follow-up from our joint survey in 2013. An invite was extended to Stuart Lovell, PFA Scotland’s liaison officer, in May 2015 via sportslabs – the only FIFA-accredited 3G test house in Scotland and our partner in this area of work. To date they have received no reply.”

The PFA declined to comment.
RELATED STORIES
  3G pitches disliked by the majority of Scottish footballers


The use of artificial turf in professional football has come under the spotlight after three- quarters of Scottish league players said they would rather play on deteriorating grass than a 3G pitch.
  FEATURE: Artificial Pitches: Maintaining artificial turf


Proper maintenance of 3G pitches can add years to the life of the surface. Eric O'Donnell from Sports Labs explains
  FA to allow artificial pitches in FA Cup


The Football Association (FA) is to allow the use of 3G artificial pitches in every round of the FA Cup, starting from next season.
  Scottish rugby and football to receive £3.15m facilities boost


A £3.15m grant has been created to develop a Scotland-wide network of full-sized 3G pitches for youth football and rugby.
MORE NEWS
HUM2N opens longevity clinic at Six Senses London
Global luxury hospitality brand, Six Senses, has partnered with longevity healthcare provider, HUM2N, to launch a clinic at Six Senses London, at The Whiteley.
KX Chelsea invests £15 million to upgrade its wellness offering
Premium London health club, KX Chelsea, will imminently unveil its most significant redevelopment since its launch in 2002 to create an integrated wellness model combining training, recovery and relaxation.
Researchers identify a drug which reduces muscle loss when using GLP-1 medications
Researchers in the US have identified an antibody which could greatly reduce the loss of lean muscle mass in people who are taking weight-loss medications.
Peloton signals potential move into reformer Pilates with Skop acquisition
Peloton has made the strategic acquisition of the Pilates start-up, Skōp, to support the expansion of its strength ecosystem.
+ More news   
LATEST JOBS
GP Exercise Referral Instructor
Everyone Active
Salary: £33,000pa + benefits
Job location: Harrow, Middlesex , United Kingdom
Self Employed Personal Trainer
Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Job location: Enderby
+ More jobs  

FEATURED SUPPLIERS

Supporting long-term health: why whole body vibration belongs in clinical settings
As healthcare continues to shift towards prevention, there’s a growing focus on helping people stay active, independent and feeling good for longer. [more...]

CoverMe extends matching service to personal training, rewriting how members and personal trainers connect
CoverMe, the global leader in fitness workforce management, today launches CoverMe PT, an on-demand personal training platform that connects the right personal trainer to the right client in under 10 seconds. [more...]
+ More featured suppliers  
COMPANY PROFILES
The Fitness Group Education

The Fitness Group is the UK’s Leading Fitness Education Training Provider. [more...]
PSLT Ltd

PSLT Fitness Solutions manufacture, remanufacture and buy back commercial gym equipment. [more...]
+ More profiles  
CATALOGUE GALLERY
 
+ More catalogues  

DIRECTORY
+ More directory  
DIARY

 

09-12 Jun 2026

W3Spa EMEA

Hotel Cascais Miragem Health & Spa, Portugal
13-13 Jun 2026

Global Wellness Day

Worldwide, Various,
+ More diary  
 
ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
 
HCM
LEISURE OPPORTUNITIES
HEALTH CLUB HANDBOOK
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
ADVERTISE . CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2026
Get HCM digital magazine and ezines FREE
Sign up here ▸
Jobs    News   Products   Magazine
NEWS
Scottish FA labels PFA 'misleading' over pitch survey
POSTED 15 Feb 2016 . BY Matthew Campelli
Hamilton Academical is one of the Scottish league teams with an artificial pitch
The Scottish Football Association (SFA) has queried the timing of survey results published by the Professional Footballers’ Association (PFA) in relation to artificial pitches, and labelled statements made by the body “misleading”.

Last week, the PFA published the results which revealed 73 per cent of the 705 professional players questioned would rather play on deteriorating grass than a 3G pitch, while 72 per cent believed that synthetic pitches were more likely to cause injuries.

However, the SFA said that it was “surprised” by the timing of publication, as the results formed part of a joint survey between the SFA and PFA – the Professional Player & Artificial Turf survey – conducted in 2013.

The governing body also said comments made by PFA chief executive Fraser Wishart about the variance in pitch quality and the risks they pose to players were “misleading”.

“While most players, given the choice, said they would prefer to play on natural grass, it is inaccurate and misleading to say ‘the vast majority of players wanted to avoid astroturf’. In actual fact, 42.5 per cent of respondents supported the use of synthetic surfaces in competitive matches,” said the SFA via a statement.

The SFA added that all 3G pitches used in league competition in Scotland are “required to be annually certified” to FIFA standards to satisfy Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL) rules.

“The SPFL has also implemented an innovative ‘spot-testing’ protocol to ensure these standards are maintained throughout the season – the only league in the world to do so,” the statement continued.

A piece of British Medical Journal research – titled Risk of Injury on 3G Artificial Turf in Norwegian Professional Football – was put forward by the SFA. It showed that 17.1 injuries were incurred per 1,000 matches on natural grass compared with 17.6 injuries on artificial turf.

The SFA concluded: “Finally we welcome Fraser’s request to follow-up from our joint survey in 2013. An invite was extended to Stuart Lovell, PFA Scotland’s liaison officer, in May 2015 via sportslabs – the only FIFA-accredited 3G test house in Scotland and our partner in this area of work. To date they have received no reply.”

The PFA declined to comment.
RELATED STORIES
3G pitches disliked by the majority of Scottish footballers


The use of artificial turf in professional football has come under the spotlight after three- quarters of Scottish league players said they would rather play on deteriorating grass than a 3G pitch.
FEATURE: Artificial Pitches: Maintaining artificial turf


Proper maintenance of 3G pitches can add years to the life of the surface. Eric O'Donnell from Sports Labs explains
FA to allow artificial pitches in FA Cup


The Football Association (FA) is to allow the use of 3G artificial pitches in every round of the FA Cup, starting from next season.
Scottish rugby and football to receive £3.15m facilities boost


A £3.15m grant has been created to develop a Scotland-wide network of full-sized 3G pitches for youth football and rugby.
MORE NEWS
HUM2N opens longevity clinic at Six Senses London
Global luxury hospitality brand, Six Senses, has partnered with longevity healthcare provider, HUM2N, to launch a clinic at Six Senses London, at The Whiteley.
KX Chelsea invests £15 million to upgrade its wellness offering
Premium London health club, KX Chelsea, will imminently unveil its most significant redevelopment since its launch in 2002 to create an integrated wellness model combining training, recovery and relaxation.
Researchers identify a drug which reduces muscle loss when using GLP-1 medications
Researchers in the US have identified an antibody which could greatly reduce the loss of lean muscle mass in people who are taking weight-loss medications.
Peloton signals potential move into reformer Pilates with Skop acquisition
Peloton has made the strategic acquisition of the Pilates start-up, Skōp, to support the expansion of its strength ecosystem.
Crunch Fitness creates more affordable reformer Pilates concept
Crunch Fitness has announced the launch of Crunch Reform Pilates – its own reformer concept designed to bring this fast growing, but rather expensive, modality into the mainstream.
As the 20th State of the Industry Report is released, LeisureDB rebrands to Evolve
The 20th State of the Industry Report reveals a resilient, expanding and competitive sector, the importance of differentiation and the ongoing challenge of tackling inequalities.
+ More news   
 
FEATURED SUPPLIERS

Supporting long-term health: why whole body vibration belongs in clinical settings
As healthcare continues to shift towards prevention, there’s a growing focus on helping people stay active, independent and feeling good for longer. [more...]

CoverMe extends matching service to personal training, rewriting how members and personal trainers connect
CoverMe, the global leader in fitness workforce management, today launches CoverMe PT, an on-demand personal training platform that connects the right personal trainer to the right client in under 10 seconds. [more...]
+ More featured suppliers  
COMPANY PROFILES
The Fitness Group Education

The Fitness Group is the UK’s Leading Fitness Education Training Provider. [more...]
+ More profiles  
CATALOGUE GALLERY
+ More catalogues  

DIRECTORY
+ More directory  
DIARY

 

09-12 Jun 2026

W3Spa EMEA

Hotel Cascais Miragem Health & Spa, Portugal
13-13 Jun 2026

Global Wellness Day

Worldwide, Various,
+ More diary  
 


ADVERTISE . CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2026

ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS