Get HCM digital magazine and ezines FREE
Sign up here ▸
Jobs   News   Features   Products   Magazine      Advertise  
Letters
Write to reply

Retention isn’t only about staff–member interaction


I’m writing regarding your recent three-part retention series (see HCM May, June and July 13). It’s not that I disagree with Guy Griffiths: I’m sure operators would improve retention if his advice were followed. However, what I take issue with is the one-dimensional aspect of every retention discussion that takes place in the fitness sector. It seems the industry views retention as a simple equation of ‘retention = staff engagement with customers’.

The discussion must be expanded, recognising other aspects of the customer experience that affect retention.

We’ve been measuring the ‘availability’ of gym equipment for two and a half years now, and have seen that when a gym is at full capacity and customers can no longer easily get on equipment, the membership base stops growing. As fast as the sales team sells memberships, existing customers leave. When gyms solve equipment bottlenecks in specific areas, removing kit that’s not being used and adding more of the popular stations, membership grows. In one site that had an overall capacity shortage and expanded the whole gym, direct debits increased by £420k p.a.

Simply put, customers stop coming to gyms when they can’t get on the kit they want, when they want, and this has a massive impact on retention.

But what of the retention impact of improving the aircon system, changing rooms, AV entertainment, cleanliness...?

These aspects, and many others, will have an impact. To move beyond the 12 per cent penetration rate, I believe the industry needs to research the impact of other value drivers on retention, and not only focus on customer engagement. Rory McGown, Founder, GYMetrix
New study will link retention with member characteristics

I agree with the editor that using crude member groupings to inform engagement strategies can lead to discord between member and club (see HCM July 13, p5). Unfortunately the majority of clubs, and the industry as a whole, only have limited information on which to base any groupings.

The Retention People’s TRP 10,000© study, which I am leading, aims to do exactly what the editor proposes. The study will survey and follow 10,000 club members and investigate the interaction between member characteristics, motivations, values, club activities and retention. One of the key outcomes of the research will be to understand what kinds of members, with what motivations, engage in particular club activities at various frequencies during different periods of their membership.

In addition, we will be examining the value members place on different communication channels, from reception and fitness staff to SMS, email and social media. The first results from the study will appear towards the end of the year.

Dr Melvyn Hillsdon
Physical activity researcher

 


photo: shutterstock.com/ Deklofenak

The retention study will follow and survey 10,000 club members
FEATURED SUPPLIERS

CoverMe extends matching service to personal training, rewriting how members and personal trainers connect
CoverMe, the global leader in fitness workforce management, today launches CoverMe PT, an on-demand personal training platform that connects the right personal trainer to the right client in under 10 seconds. [more...]

Cornerstone Connect helps Active Blackpool tackle health inequalities
Active Blackpool is deploying Cornerstone Connect, a new digital interface allowing disparate information from multiple systems to be aggregated into one dataset, to support its focus on reducing health inequalities and improving healthy life expectancy. [more...]
+ More featured suppliers  
COMPANY PROFILES
The Fitness Group Education

The Fitness Group provides education and workforce development for learners and fitness operators. [more...]
Precor

Precor promises precision-quality products with steadfast reliability that are inspired by exerciser [more...]
+ More profiles  
CATALOGUE GALLERY
 
+ More catalogues  

DIRECTORY
+ More directory  
DIARY

 

23-26 Aug 2026

Elevate Spa Riviera Maya Edition

The Riviera Maya Edition Kanai, Playa del Carmen, Mexico
10-12 Sep 2026

ASEAN Patio Pool Spa Expo 2026

MITEC Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia, Malaysia
+ More diary  
 
ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
 
HCM
LEISURE OPPORTUNITIES
HEALTH CLUB HANDBOOK
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
ADVERTISE . CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2026
Get HCM digital magazine and ezines FREE
Sign up here ▸
Jobs    News   Products   Magazine
Letters
Write to reply

Retention isn’t only about staff–member interaction


I’m writing regarding your recent three-part retention series (see HCM May, June and July 13). It’s not that I disagree with Guy Griffiths: I’m sure operators would improve retention if his advice were followed. However, what I take issue with is the one-dimensional aspect of every retention discussion that takes place in the fitness sector. It seems the industry views retention as a simple equation of ‘retention = staff engagement with customers’.

The discussion must be expanded, recognising other aspects of the customer experience that affect retention.

We’ve been measuring the ‘availability’ of gym equipment for two and a half years now, and have seen that when a gym is at full capacity and customers can no longer easily get on equipment, the membership base stops growing. As fast as the sales team sells memberships, existing customers leave. When gyms solve equipment bottlenecks in specific areas, removing kit that’s not being used and adding more of the popular stations, membership grows. In one site that had an overall capacity shortage and expanded the whole gym, direct debits increased by £420k p.a.

Simply put, customers stop coming to gyms when they can’t get on the kit they want, when they want, and this has a massive impact on retention.

But what of the retention impact of improving the aircon system, changing rooms, AV entertainment, cleanliness...?

These aspects, and many others, will have an impact. To move beyond the 12 per cent penetration rate, I believe the industry needs to research the impact of other value drivers on retention, and not only focus on customer engagement. Rory McGown, Founder, GYMetrix
New study will link retention with member characteristics

I agree with the editor that using crude member groupings to inform engagement strategies can lead to discord between member and club (see HCM July 13, p5). Unfortunately the majority of clubs, and the industry as a whole, only have limited information on which to base any groupings.

The Retention People’s TRP 10,000© study, which I am leading, aims to do exactly what the editor proposes. The study will survey and follow 10,000 club members and investigate the interaction between member characteristics, motivations, values, club activities and retention. One of the key outcomes of the research will be to understand what kinds of members, with what motivations, engage in particular club activities at various frequencies during different periods of their membership.

In addition, we will be examining the value members place on different communication channels, from reception and fitness staff to SMS, email and social media. The first results from the study will appear towards the end of the year.

Dr Melvyn Hillsdon
Physical activity researcher

 


photo: shutterstock.com/ Deklofenak

The retention study will follow and survey 10,000 club members
LATEST NEWS
UK updates physical activity guidelines with focus on daily movement
The UK's four Chief Medical Officers have published a refreshed edition of Physical activity guidelines: UK Chief Medical Officers' report, updating the evidence that underpins the nation's physical activity recommendations and placing greater emphasis on strength, balance, reducing sedentary behaviour and, for the first time, supporting people taking weight loss medications.
Places Leisure is working with Roberts Limbrick to build £60m wellness flagship in Basingstoke
Places Leisure has exchanged contracts to build and operate a flagship £60m water and leisure destination on behalf of Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council.
PureGym announces expansion into Ireland
The Republic of Ireland will become the latest market in PureGym’s expanding international portfolio, with the first launch planned for Dublin in 2027.
Total Fitness CEO Sophie Lawler launches leadership coaching venture
Sophie Lawler, CEO of Total Fitness, has launched a leadership coaching business aimed at helping women realise their professional potential.
Anytime Fitness targets Europe after opening a club a day in 2025
Anytime Fitness opened more than one club a day in 2025 and is on track to maintain this rate of growth this year, as parent company Purpose Brands targets further international expansion.
Everyone Active opens £33.9 million next-generation leisure and wellbeing hub
The £33.9 million Leighton Leisure and Community Centre has opened in Leighton Buzzard, UK, creating a next-generation public leisure, health and wellbeing hub for the local community.
YogaSix responds to Pilates boom with launch of strength-focused Y6 Core class
YogaSix, the yoga brand of Xponential Fitness, has launched a heated, Pilates-inspired class called Y6 Core.
Bromley’s £17m Walnuts revamp adds EGYM, rehab and recovery
Walnuts Leisure Centre in Orpington, in the London Borough of Bromley, has reopened following a £17m transformation designed to secure the long-term future of the public leisure asset and reposition it as a community wellbeing hub.
The Gym Group breaks the million members mark for the first time
The Gym Group, has announced that it's sustained positive trading momentum has continued through the first half of 2026 and the company remains confident about the outlook.
Hyrox offers charity spots in sold-out races
Hyrox has announced it will be working with a second charity in the upcoming season and offering charity spots in sold-out races.
Amped Fitness debuts Amped Universe flagship
US low-cost operator, Amped Fitness, has launched a flagship location in Texas, debuting its multi-sensory Amped Universe design architecture.
X-Club gears up to open its flagship site in central London
Luxury boutique Pilates and wellness studio, X-Club, officially launches a 4,000sq ft flagship at Marylebone on 16 July Built around X-Club’s four pillars of wellness – mind, movement, nutrition and therapy – the facility features two group exercise studi
+ More news   
 
FEATURED SUPPLIERS

CoverMe extends matching service to personal training, rewriting how members and personal trainers connect
CoverMe, the global leader in fitness workforce management, today launches CoverMe PT, an on-demand personal training platform that connects the right personal trainer to the right client in under 10 seconds. [more...]

Cornerstone Connect helps Active Blackpool tackle health inequalities
Active Blackpool is deploying Cornerstone Connect, a new digital interface allowing disparate information from multiple systems to be aggregated into one dataset, to support its focus on reducing health inequalities and improving healthy life expectancy. [more...]
+ More featured suppliers  
COMPANY PROFILES
The Fitness Group Education

The Fitness Group provides education and workforce development for learners and fitness operators. [more...]
+ More profiles  
CATALOGUE GALLERY
+ More catalogues  

DIRECTORY
+ More directory  
DIARY

 

23-26 Aug 2026

Elevate Spa Riviera Maya Edition

The Riviera Maya Edition Kanai, Playa del Carmen, Mexico
10-12 Sep 2026

ASEAN Patio Pool Spa Expo 2026

MITEC Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia, Malaysia
+ More diary  
 


ADVERTISE . CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2026

ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS